Soft Plaque vs Calcium Score: What Each Test Can See
Andrew founded Renew Health to change how cardiovascular disease is detected and treated.
A calcium score counts hardened, calcified plaque. Soft plaque is plaque that has not calcified, and a standard calcium scan cannot measure it. Al-Muhaidb and colleagues describe the timeline: However, coronary plaque calcification is a late manifestation of atherosclerosis, and earlier stages of atherosclerosis present noncalcified plaques (NCPs) and plaques with a mixed composition containing extracellular lipid and fibrous tissue (Al-Muhaidb et al., Coronary Artery Disease 2021).
That gap is the reason this comparison matters. A low or zero calcium score is reassuring, yet it says nothing direct about soft plaque. This page defines both, explains how each is detected, what soft plaque means clinically, how to read a calcium score with this gap in mind, what the risk data show, when each scan fits, and what neither test can do.
What soft plaque is
Soft plaque, also called noncalcified plaque, is a buildup in the artery wall made mostly of fat, fibrous tissue, and inflammatory cells. On CT angiography, Al-Muhaidb and colleagues define it this way: NCP was defined as any discernible structure that could be assigned to the coronary artery wall, with a CT number below the contrast-enhanced coronary lumen but above the surrounding connective tissue and that could be identified in at least two independent planes.
Plaque tends to start soft. Maniar and colleagues write: Initially, coronary plaque is predominantly noncalcified and at higher risk for rupture (Maniar et al., Clinical Cardiology 2022).
What a calcium score is
A calcium score is a number from a noncontrast heart CT that adds up calcified plaque in the coronary arteries. Obisesan and colleagues describe it as a readout of a person's overall plaque load in the coronary arteries (Obisesan et al., Radiology: Cardiothoracic Imaging 2021). Even though it counts only the hardened part, it tracks the total. Maniar and colleagues note that CAC is directly linked to the total amount of plaque (Maniar et al., Clinical Cardiology 2022). How the scan is done and what it costs in radiation are covered in what is a coronary calcium score.
Detection methods: CT vs CT angiography
The two tests use the same kind of scanner in different ways.
- Calcium scan. A short, ECG-timed CT with no dye. Neves and colleagues note it is done with no contrast injected into a vein (Neves et al., Radiologia Brasileira 2017). It sees calcium and gives a number.
- CT angiography (CCTA). Contrast dye goes through an IV so the inside of the artery lights up. Ngam and colleagues write: Current scanners can differentiate between calcified plaques and non-calcified plaques (NCPs) (Ngam and Ong, Singapore Medical Journal 2020).
CCTA can also flag plaque features linked to future events. Ngam and colleagues describe how it can identify vulnerable plaques that show the features of positive remodelling, low attenuation (< 30 Hounsfield units [HU]), the napkin-ring sign and spotty calcification. It has limits of its own. They add: However, the sub-classification of NCPs into lipid-rich and fibrous lesions remains challenging, as there is substantial overlap in plaque densities, preventing reliable sub-classification.
CCTA also uses more radiation than a calcium scan and requires dye. Dose figures for CT angiography and a side-by-side of both tests are on calcium score vs CT angiogram.
Clinical significance of soft plaque
Soft plaque matters because it can rupture. Al-Muhaidb and colleagues note: Such plaques are also prone to rupture and thrombosis causing acute coronary syndrome. They also point to the imaging features tied to later events: Studies using CCTA have demonstrated as association between four major plaque characteristics and future of acute coronary syndrome: positive remodeling, low attenuation plaque, spotty calcification, and napkin ring sign.
How common is soft plaque when the calcium score is zero? In their study of symptomatic patients with a zero score who had CT angiography, Al-Muhaidb and colleagues found: Results The prevalence of NCP was 6.4% (19 of the 299). Most of those plaques caused little narrowing. They report: Among the 19 patients with NCP, 52.6% had no identified coronary artery stenosis, 26.3% had less than 25%, and 21% had stenosis between 25 and 50%.
Risk factors made soft plaque more likely in that study. The authors write that NCP is more common in males, in patients with hypertension, and active smokers. That group was symptomatic, so the numbers do not apply directly to people without symptoms. The authors say so, noting that the prevalence of NCP in asymptomatic patients cannot be determined based on our data.
Interpreting calcium score values with soft plaque in mind
A positive calcium score is reliable. Shah and Coulter write that any calcium points to underlying coronary disease, with essentially no false positives (Shah and Coulter, Tex Heart Inst J 2012). If calcium is present, soft plaque is often present too, since calcium marks the total burden.
A zero score is where soft plaque matters most. The 2019 ACC/AHA guideline says that in smokers, people with diabetes, and people with a family history, a zero score does not exclude risk from noncalcified plaque or a higher risk of clotting (Arnett et al., Circulation 2019). What a zero predicts over 10 years, and when it is less reassuring, is on calcium score of 0.
Risk stratification and prognosis
Calcium scores predict events well despite missing soft plaque. In MESA, Budoff and colleagues found that event rates climbed with each calcium band, and that this held regardless of race or ethnicity, age, sex, or education (Budoff et al., European Heart Journal 2018). A zero score carries low risk. Czaja-Ziółkowska and colleagues note that zero CACS practically excludes coronary atherosclerosis in subjects with a low pre-test probability of CAD (Czaja-Ziółkowska et al., Adv Interv Cardiol 2022).
Plaque burden, more than narrowing, drives risk. Cardoso and colleagues describe the PROMISE trial result: Similarly, in the Prospective Multicenter Imaging Study for Evaluation of Chest Pain (PROMISE) study, the majority of patients who experienced an adverse event had underlying plaque (in the CCTA arm), but no ischemia (in the functional testing arm), which implicates nonobstructive plaques as the most likely culprits. (Cardoso et al., American Journal of Preventive Cardiology 2022)
When to get a scan
A calcium scan is a screening test for adults without symptoms whose risk is uncertain. The 2019 guideline says that for many adults at intermediate risk, a calcium score can meaningfully change the risk estimate (Arnett et al., Circulation 2019).
CCTA is mainly a diagnostic test for people with symptoms. Cardoso and colleagues summarize the chest pain guideline, which gives CCTA its strongest rating (class 1, level A) for diagnosing coronary disease, sorting risk, and guiding treatment in people with stable chest pain and no known CAD (Cardoso et al., American Journal of Preventive Cardiology 2022). Al-Muhaidb and colleagues add a caution on using it more widely: the benefit of finding noncalcified plaque has to be weighed against the radiation the test delivers (Al-Muhaidb et al., Coronary Artery Disease 2021).
Limitations of calcium scoring
The calcium scan misses soft plaque by design. It also does not show narrowing or blood flow. Some calcium may even be protective. Obisesan and colleagues write that denser CAC are more indicative of stable plaques, which are less prone to rupture (6,28).
CCTA has its own limits. Al-Muhaidb and colleagues note that CCTA probably underestimates the extent of plaque burden; if intravascular ultrasound had been performed on these patients, an even greater degree of NCP may have been detected. Neither test replaces a risk discussion. To see how an ultrasound of the neck arteries looks at the artery wall instead, read CIMT vs calcium score.
What to do, in order
- Know which test you had. A calcium scan and CT angiography answer different questions.
- If your score is zero, check your risk factors. Smoking, diabetes, and family history change what zero means.
- If you have symptoms, see a clinician now. A calcium scan is the wrong test for chest pain.
- Fill the gap the calcium number leaves. CIMT looks at carotid wall thickness, and Renew can help you decide whether that ultrasound fits.
FAQ
What is the difference between soft plaque and a calcium score?
A calcium score measures only hardened, calcified plaque in the heart arteries using a standard CT scan, while soft plaque consists of uncalcified, fatty, or inflamed deposits that a standard calcium scan cannot see (Ngam and Ong, Singapore Medical Journal 2020).
Why does soft plaque matter?
Soft plaque is more prone to rupturing and forming an acute blood clot, which can trigger a sudden heart attack or stroke even if a calcium score is low or zero (Al-Muhaidb et al., Coronary Artery Disease 2021).
Can a calcium scan see soft plaque?
It is invisible on a basic calcium scan (Arnett et al., Circulation 2019).
Sources
- Arnett DK, et al. 2019 ACC/AHA Guideline on the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease. Circulation. 2019.
- Obisesan OH, et al. An Update on Coronary Artery Calcium Interpretation at Chest and Cardiac CT. Radiol Cardiothorac Imaging. 2021.
- Neves PO, et al. Coronary artery calcium score: current status. Radiol Bras. 2017.
- Budoff MJ, et al. Ten-year association of coronary artery calcium with ASCVD events: MESA. Eur Heart J. 2018.
- Cardoso R, et al. Preventive cardiology advances in the 2021 AHA/ACC chest pain guideline. Am J Prev Cardiol. 2022.
- Al-Muhaidb S, et al. Prevalence of noncalcified plaques and coronary artery stenosis in patients with coronary calcium scores of zero. Coron Artery Dis. 2021.
- Maniar Y, et al. The ABCs of CAC: coronary artery calcium in allocating pharmacotherapy for primary prevention. Clin Cardiol. 2022.
- Czaja-Ziółkowska MZ, et al. An update on the coronary calcium score: a review for clinicians. Postepy Kardiol Interwencyjnej. 2022.
- Shah NR, Coulter SA. An evidence-based guide for coronary calcium scoring in asymptomatic patients without coronary heart disease. Tex Heart Inst J. 2012.
- Ngam PI, Ong CC, et al. Computed tomography coronary angiography: past, present and future. Singapore Med J. 2020.
Author
Written by Andrew Le, MD. Andrew Le, MD reviews patient-facing guidance for Renew Health with a focus on preventive cardiology and functional medicine clarity.
Next step
Questions about plaque the calcium scan cannot see? Start with CIMT, or contact Renew and attach the report you already have.
Part of our Vascular Imaging guide
Ready to see your actual risk?
Advanced metabolic testing, arterial imaging, and a personalized prevention plan, built around your numbers.
View Memberships